Adding New Hens to an Existing Flock Without a Bloodbath
The pecking order is not a metaphor. Hens settle it with their beaks, and a badly managed introduction can leave a bird injured or dead in an afternoon. Done properly it is a two week nuisance and then it is over.
Never add one bird alone
A single newcomer absorbs the entire flock's attention and has nowhere to retreat. Two or three arrivals spread the pressure out and have each other for company. If your plan is one hen, make it two.
Quarantine first, and not for manners
Keep new birds completely separate for two to four weeks, ideally out of sight, with their own feed and water and their own boots if you can manage it. This step is about disease. Respiratory infections and mites walk in with apparently healthy birds all the time, and losing a whole flock is a very high price for skipping two weeks.
See but do not touch
After quarantine, put the newcomers where the flock can see them but not reach them. A wire partition across the run works, so does a dog crate set inside it. A week of this does most of the work for you. The confrontation still happens, but it happens after the novelty has worn off, and that takes most of the heat out of it.
Then open the door, with an escape route
Let them mix in the run rather than the coop, and pick a day when you are around. Make sure there is more space than usual, at least two feeders and two waterers set well apart, and something to hide behind or get up onto. Most serious injuries happen when a bullied hen has nowhere left to go.
💡 Chasing, squabbling and a few pulled feathers are normal and should settle within a week or two. Blood is not. Chickens will keep pecking at a wound once it is open, so separate an injured bird immediately rather than hoping it calms down.
The night trick
Some keepers slip newcomers onto the roost after dark so the flock wakes up with them already there. It sometimes helps and it never replaces the steps above. Whatever happens at dawn is what you were going to get anyway.
Before any new bird joins the flock, check her carefully: how to spot mites and lice.